Komminsk's opinion on Travis Hafner's Eastern League appearance
With the Cleveland Indians in town, it seemed like an appropriate time to ask Double-A Bowie manager Brad Komminsk about Travis Hafner's inclusion on Akron's roster for the last two games of the Easten League Southern Division playoffs - and the grand slam and two-run shot that Hafner contributed while the Aeros were eliminating the Baysox.
No surprisingly, Komminsk wasn't a huge fan of the Indians' decision to assign Hafner to Akron as part of an injury rehab assignment. And this is coming from someone who managed the Aeros for three seasons and worked in the Indians' player development system for eight years.
"They had him in (Triple-A) Buffalo for three weeks," Komminsk said. "In my opinion, why bring him to Akron when he could have been on the big league roster? I talked to the farm director and they thought about sending him to A ball, but they wanted him to play at the highest level. I told him the big leagues are the highest level.
"(The Indians) aren't going to the playoffs. They have no chance of winning. Why he couldn't go there and do what he's been doing makes no sense to me. I think they brought (Jeremy) Sowers down last year, too. I think you should go with the guys you had. We could have had Melvin Mora down here or Chris Ray, but what's the point? Ray would have been a logical choice, since he rehabbed for us already. Hafner rehabbed in Buffalo for about three weeks. He had 20 or 30 at-bats at Triple-A. It would have been easy to slide him back into the (Indians') lineup. And I don't think those eight at-bats (with Akron) made a difference for him.
"It didn't sit well with me. I talked to people in different organizations and they all said the same thing. For that time of the year, it's not the right thing to do. But this isn't sour grapes. They're a good team. They played us well all year. Our numbers were almost identical if you look them up - runs, doubles, triples home runs, RBIs, all that stuff. It's uncanny how close it was. But you get (Hafner), and it just changes the whole complexion of the game. A big leaguer hits a grand slam and you have to make up four runs. It's a tie game if you take him out of there. And the next day, when he hit that two-run jack, you could see it take the wind out of their sails."
Komminsk broke down some of the prospects on Bowie's roster, which I'll save for another time. I'm heading to the gym and then the ballpark. We'll talk later.
![]() |
Categories (click for archive)Roch Kubatko |












Thanks for the info Roch - it's nice to hear the manager's opinion on all of this. Any way you know of that the club could petition to get the rules changed for the future? I guess in the grand scheme of things it's not a huge deal, but it really was unfair (especially now learning that Hafner had been rehabbing w/AAA for 3 weeks!) I know I should drop it, but I just really can't stand the injustice of it. As always, thanks for your info & insight :)
Roch,
Don't they have rules in the minor league to handle situations like that? It seems chaos prone if they allow this type of player movement during the minor league playoffs.
I can't say that I disagree with anything that Komminsk had to say. I realize that the minor leagues are there to be the feeder for the big league club, but I just think that when it comes to a playoff situation that these young guys have fought all season to get to it's a little cruddy to send an established ML guy on a rehab assignment. The Aeros very well may have won the series against the Baysox without him, but how unfortunate that the victory is a bit tainted by Hafner being a key player in it all.
I would have walked him every time up no matter what. Don't give him the at bats. One run would have been better then 4 or even 2.
Jerry's right- walk the SOB to prove your point- and feelings that he didnt need the extra AB!
Roch,
Thanks for the interview. But why did he let his pitchers throw even one pitch to Hafner? They should have walked him every time he came up--period. Bad call by the Baysox manager. Nevertheless, the Indians organization can say whatever they want. They have sunk to a new low. Shame on them!!!!!